Skip to main content

Here's Where to Find the Best Pie in Wichita

Here's Where to Find the Best Pie in Wichita

You don't have to wait for a major holiday to find delicious pies in Wichita, KS. Wichita's pie makers are always whipping up something fabulous. When you have a hankering for a pecan pie, cream pie, or chicken pot pie, there are many local shops to choose from. 

With its thriving diner and bakery scene, Wichita is the perfect place for pie lovers. Whether you enjoy a flaky crust, seasonal fruit, or savory fillings, you're guaranteed to find something that suits your tastes! From French bakeries with authentic tarts and tortes to charming cafes with unbelievable fruit pies and award-winning coffee, Wichita has it all. If you live in Wichita and you're looking for the best pies near me, check out these top-rated local spots. 


Milkfloat 

The pies sold by the slice at Milkfloat are among the best pies in Wichita, KS. Located in the heart of Wichita's Delano neighborhood, Milkfloat focuses on whimsical flavors and sources only the finest ingredients. From creamy and fluffy to fruity and covered with ice cream, they offer an impressive selection of seasonal pies by the slice. This is the place to visit when you have a sweet tooth but want something a bit different. You can sample options like: 

  • Key lime pie 
  • German chocolate pie 
  • Peanut butter pie 
  • Oreo pie 
  • Turtle brownie pie 

Pies from Milkfloat tick all the most common pie-lover boxes. Expect buttery, flaky crusts, unique flavors, and toe-curling decadence. Served with Tillamook's vanilla bean ice cream, pie slices from Milkfloat are the ideal way to treat yourself.  Milkfloat's peanut butter pie even comes with a salty pretzel crust for diners seeking the perfect sweet and salty contrast. 

A slice of key lime pie on a plate with a fork.

Spear's Restaurant & Pie Shop 

In your search for the best pies in Wichita, you'll invariably come across Spear's Restaurant & Pie Shop. Not only is Spear's a great place to order a pie to go, but it also offers an amazing dine-in experience. With a calm, comfortable aesthetic and large, street-facing windows, it's perfect for enjoying a savory meal and then relaxing over pie and coffee.  

For true pie lovers, Spear's Restaurant & Pie Shop has it all.  You can order a Dutch apple pie with cinnamon and streusel topping, cherry, blackberry, or blueberry pie, lemon supreme pie, French silk pie, or even peach streusel pie. This is the ideal pie shop for those who want variety. They have more than eight options of cream pies, seven options of fruit pies, and an incredible assortment of specialty pies. Whether you want a strawberry and rhubarb pie or an Oreo-topped pie, they have it. Spear's also serves several options of sugar-free pies. 



Frost 

If you're a traditional pie lover, stop by Frost.  Located on East Douglas Avenue, Frost sells pies just like your grandma used to make. You can buy whole pies to take home, pie-by-the-slice, or pie a la mode to eat in-house. They serve: 

  • Blueberry pie 
  • Spiced apple pie 
  • Bourbon pecan pie 
  • Cherry pie 

Frost even offers a remarkable selection of ice cream pies. These come with your choice of graham cracker, Oreo, or waffle cone crust, along with one of several current ice cream flavors. You can also indulge in a hand-held oatmeal cream pie, which some people call life-changing. 

If you're opting for a traditional fruit or pecan pie, expect melt-in-your-mouth crust and truly nostalgic flavors. Frost also sells an assortment of freshly-baked cakes that are local cult-favorites.

A slice of cherry pie on a plate with a fork.

Cheri's Bakery 

If you're wondering where to buy pies near me for special celebrations or a quick treat, try Cheri's Bakery. They sell holiday-themed pies, traditional pies, and miniature pie bites for guilt-free indulgence. Located on 21st and Tyler, Cheri's Bakery has fruit pies, crumb pies, cream pies, and seasonal offerings like pumpkin and pecan.  

You can nosh on a chocolate and peanut butter cream pie, a traditional chocolate cream pie, or a coconut cream pie. At Cheri's Bakery, diners can also order an assortment of fruit pies, including traditional and crumb versions of their apple and cherry pies. 

Although they've mastered the flaky, buttery crust, this is the perfect place to order if you're not much of a crust person. Their deep-dish crumb pies offer a sweet, crumbly alternative that eats much like a cobbler. 



Bagatelle Bakery 

For more than 40 years, Bagatelle Bakery has sold some of the best pies in Wichita, KS.  Known for their breathtaking wedding cakes and unforgettable breakfast pastries, Bagatelle Bakery maintains a mind-boggling pie menu with options to suit every palate: 

  • Sour cream apple pie 
  • Pecan chocolate pie 
  • Pumpkin pie 
  • Banana cream pie 
  • Boston cream pie 
  • Coconut cream pie 

They also serve traditional apple pie, lemon meringue pie, and more. This is the place to go for traditional flavors and classic dessert pastries. As a family-owned bakery, they use the timeless Parisian baking style to deliver world-class desserts.  

A slice of lemon meringue pie on a glass plate with a pie server.

GreenAcres Market 

If you're looking for the best savory pies in Wichita, KS, stop by GreenAcres Market. Their take-and-bake chicken pot pie comes highly reviewed, and it's made with fresh, healthy ingredients. You'll get a flaky crust, firm veggies, and delectable cuts of white and dark meat floating in sumptuous gravy.  They also offer beef and veggie pot pies, as well as a gluten-free chicken pot pie. 


La Galette French Bakery 

Stop by La Galette French Bakery to sample their tarts. Enveloped in layers of flaky, buttery puff pastry, they're like mini-pies that are perfect for one. You can choose a slightly tangy lemon curd tart for a light, refreshing dessert, or you can opt for an almond tart that's filled with a decadent, house-made lemon paste and topped with roasted, shaved almonds. La Galette tarts are ideal for those seeking small portions, quality ingredients, and an unforgettable crust. 


 


Live in Pie Central or Make Your Own 

For some people, finding the best pies in Wichita, KS is about more than scoring a satisfying dessert. It's inspiration. Wichita doesn't just have the best pie makers; it also breeds them.  

Whether you want a place to heat your take-and-bake pie from GreenAcres Market or a spacious kitchen to roll out your own crust, Ridgeport Apartments has an amazing Wichita apartment for you. The fully-equipped kitchens in our 1, 2, and 3-bedroom homes are ideal for culinary experiments, and the ceiling fans can help deal with the aftermath if your pie bubbles over in the oven! Contact Ridgeport Apartments today to schedule a tour